February 27, 2013

En Route to Knowing

I got a kick out of that movie, Night at the Museum.

Yes, it’s old, and no, we haven’t seen any of the movies that contended alongside Argo for Best Picture this year. But there were several times yesterday as clients reported results in a restive currency-addled market when I thought how things aren’t what they seem. If you could get below the surface, you’d find a tiny little tough cowboy who looked like actor Owen Wilson.

Just kidding. All analogies break down. But often in the market, what you think you’re seeing isn’t what it seems. One client’s share price shot up in the early going with results, jumping nearly 8%. Then it declined 4%. Imagine if gas prices did that every day. But I digress. The price finished right in line with the Rational level – fair market value from a fundamental perspective.

Why the gyrations? Speculators had bet on weak results (something that can be observed), and results weren’t. Traders covered, driving price up. Passive investors like indexes were Hedged. They’d farmed out risk, but surrendered upside. As price suddenly rose, counterparties with rights to gains above certain levels locked them. They’re not investors. When they sold to keep their collar profits, price reverted to the Rational level.

Market price may or may not reflect an investment purpose. Let’s use an example many can appreciate: An analyst ups her price target and rating on your shares, and price climbs 4%. We assume that investors responded. We explain to management, “Investors liked the Outperform rating and higher price target, and bought.”

But was it investment behavior? What if those gains evaporate three days later when the dollar rises100 basis points because Europeans think Italy will need more help from Germany and rush to buy dollars? That’s risk-management behavior, right?

We can accept that answer one place but we struggle to believe it in others. It’s a Night at the Museum out there. Which reminds me: ModernIR is sponsoring IR Magazine’s West Coast Think Tank next month. In our segment, we’ll do our darnedest to shed light on why markets and money behave the way they do.

Also, look for our cheeky poke at Surveillance starting next month through full-page advertisements in NIRI’s IR Update. I admit, we were cracking ourselves up. There are better – less antiquated – ways to know how investors value your shares.

Back to Behavior. Why would it matter what sort of money reacted to an analyst note anyway? And what would you do with that information? Suppose Rational investment never moved, and Speculative trading jumped 25%. You’d know what kind of money used that sellside firm’s views.

That helps set future priorities. And if your Rational price didn’t change, a market price 4% higher may be fleeting. Unless, knowing that Speculators are responsible, you call a high-turnover growth investor, just to maintain relationships. How’re the wife and kids? If that money takes the baton from speculators, maybe others follow.

And everybody wins, especially the IR chair. The possibilities are endless. They start with moving from assuming to knowing. That’s something you won’t find in a museum. But I can’t say you’ll see Owen Wilson.

Share this article:

More posts

dreamstime m 189412296
July 24, 2024

Vice President Calvin Coolidge assumed the Presidency of the United States on the death of President Harding and completed that term and was then elected...

dreamstime m 80170758
July 17, 2024

The Dow Industrials gained 742 points yesterday. Randomly.  The rest of the market was pedestrian.  The trouble for issuers and investors alike is the comparisons. ...

dreamstime m 10641082
July 10, 2024

It’s worth stopping whatever you’re doing and observing what’s occurring on the planet.  In South Africa, the African National Congress is out for the first...

dreamstime m 84244231
July 3, 2024

There’s a moat between haves and have-nots in the stock market.  The S&P 500 Equal Weight Index that treats the 500 components the same is...

dreamstime m 27911598
June 26, 2024

Why are the Nasdaq and the Dow Jones Industrial Average diverging wildly?  It might resolve in the next few days.  But it’s not small. Back...

dreamstime m 105330423
June 19, 2024

One of our customers at EDGE calculated that 82% of Demand in the S&P 500 is from three stocks (NVDA – now the largest –...