February 4, 2015

Function Follows Form

Let me go. I don’t want to be your hero.

Those words strung together move me now viscerally after seeing the movie Boyhood, in the running at the Academy Awards, as I write, for best of the year. I’m biased by the video for “Hero” from the band Family of the Year because it highlights rodeo, something bled into the DNA of my youth.  See both. The movie is a cinematic achievement that left us blurry. The song is one I wish I’d had the talent in youth to write.

As ever for the ear that hears and the eye that sees, there’s a lesson for investor-relations. We might have heard MSCI last week refraining those lyrics – let me go, I don’t want to be your hero – to the ValueAct team, activist investors.

Over the past few years as activism has flourished, many companies have longed to be let go but have benefited from the activist grip. Herbalife and Bill Ackman.  Hewlett-Packard and Relational Investors. Dow Chemical and Dan Loeb’s Third Point.  Tessera and Wausau Paper and a raft of others just off Starboard.  On it goes, all around.

A curious condition has laid hold of stocks in the last number of years. It used to be that results differentiated.  Deliver consistent topline and bottom-line performance, do what you say you’ll do, explain it in predictable cadence each quarter – these were a reliable recipe for capital-markets rewards. Form followed function.

Activism by its nature supposes something amiss – that a feature of the form of a company is incorrect or undervalued, or simply operated poorly. By calling attention like the old flashing blue light at Kmart (have I just dated myself?), activists have often outperformed the market.

Meanwhile, the opposite has become more than an exception.  From our own client base we could cull a meaningful percentage of companies following the formula of consistent performance yet missing bigger prizes.

What’s going on?  There’s a brief image in Boyhood of a pastel-colored triangular Apple Mac.  Remember those?  Seeing it skipped me mentally backward in time – stories are time-travel – to Apple’s iconic 1984 commercial with its Orwellian theme of smashing convention illustrated through a hurled hammer crashing through a giant video screen.

In Apple’s commercial, someone broke out of barcode mode, the relentless patterned march, to heave a weapon at conformity.  One of my college professors called this notion Yellow Pencil Theory.  If society and academia are conformed to a standard, the products the standard generates all look the same. A bunch of yellow pencils.

What’s the market-cap factory today?  Sure, corporate results are important. But that’s not the function or form of investment behavior now.  Blackrock and Vanguard dominate an environment predicated on allocation. Target-date funds.  Exchange-traded funds.  Mutual funds.  Over 65% of investment-company assets march along this line.

And we have a National Market System, a marketplace that conforms to rules connecting competitors around price. Over the weekend word broke that the NYSE has asked regulators permission for a midday auction, something to shake up the model.  We’ll write more about this later, but it’s a struggle against conformity. The NYSE cannot operate its business like other businesses can, making decisions that suit its own interests.

All exchanges have to get a barcode before doing something different.  They must seek the leave of regulators, so it won’t be TOO different from the standard. In fact, the market’s success measures reflective collective conformity. Best execution, as defined.  Best price, as defined.  And so on.

We at ModernIR generally are anti-activism because the thesis implies that the market can’t value businesses properly. But activism is a typological hammer through the screen. Activists may not realize it but they repudiate the barcoded nature of today’s market, where function follows prescribed form.

Good companies can struggle to stand out from the crowd because the crowd allocates assets according to a central tendency. It’s not looking for outliers. A market defined around averages punishes achievement by reducing its relative value (stock-picking struggles because arbitragers periodically punch achievers back into conformity with broad measures).

That’s a profound sociological concept, beyond the stock market. We need heroes and yet the market we’ve got depends on uniformity. Averages. So let me go. I can’t be your hero.

The solution is both so enormous as to seem impossible and yet so simple as to be elegant. The problem is that the solution requires more hammers through screens.

Share this article:
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

More posts

SPGlobal 2024 Capital Flows
February 5, 2025

“Really? That’s all the time you spent?” I said,”Yessir. It doesn’t take long to pull weeds.” I think I was twelve.  The mailman had suggested...

dreamstime m 135367887
January 29, 2025

DeepSeek would be a great name for a rock band. As would Rapeseed, an alternative offered by the helpful Whole Foods staff when I asked...

dreamstime m 6354515
January 22, 2025

A headline at Bloomberg from Jan 13, 2025, reads: I was a Wall Street Analyst. They are Irrelevant. The article by opinion columnist Shuli Ren...

dreamstime m 350316889
January 15, 2025
Public companies with traded shares need to stop selling horses and wagons to a stock market buying cars....
Public companies with traded shares need to stop selling horses and wagons to a stock market buying cars.
dreamstime m 116868429
January 8, 2025

We were in Nashville and Keith Urban wished us a happy new year. If you like country music, that’s a good start to 2025. More...

PXL 20240512 145600530.PORTRAIT
December 18, 2024

Willie Nelson plays Johnny Dean in the 1997 Barry Levinson movie Wag the Dog, who is hired to write a patriotic song as part of...