July 27, 2010

Market Sentiment a Mix of Reactions

The saying goes that you’re better off keeping your mouth closed and looking like a fool than opening it and removing all doubt. Trading reminded us again about the wisdom in those words.

We’d warned that markets showed excessive arbitrage. Arbs capture net spreads between opposing trades and care little about price appreciation. When it’s high in the broad markets (and in specific issues, too), it often points to impending switches in the direction of money, say from one mix of assets to another. Why? Traders apparently detect algorithmic activity and move to profit from it.

We’d seen the same thing in June and thought it might occur again. It didn’t, and the market removed all doubt that we were the fools we appeared to be.

Or so it seems. Are investors responsible for this nice recent run back to positive turf on the major market measures? We can only share general observations from data. The data are what they are. We observed two developments on 7/22. First, Nomura traded more than half our client base that day, a rarity. Nomura had become a primary dealer to the Spanish Treasury a few days earlier, and it’s also a primary dealer for the US Treasury. It owns the trading platform Instinet and Lehman’s Asian and European operations.

How do those facts bear on equity trading when treasuries are a credit market? We can only speculate. But we believe banks can effect carry trades – borrowing and paying interest to earn higher interest on something else.

At the same time Nomura rippled through equity markets, we saw a surge in conventional program trading. Our measures differ from what the exchanges use. Different kinds mean different things. In this case, it was the biggest firms helping global institutions manage transitions from one asset class to another. While market volumes have been relatively light, this increase in market share by big program traders attracted a surge in mathematical trading, which identifies disparities in market structure and capitalizes on them.

Together these could represent a bait-and-switch, not fundamental investment. Banks with trading technologies and commitments to governments to help them fund operations could get money from overnight treasury or central-bank facilities at low cost and use it to trade in equity markets and attract demand. Profits from these operations provide funds for use in required bidding at government primary-dealer auctions. It also gives the bond market a head feint by pulling demand to equities to improve bond-market rates and prices.

We’re not saying this happened. But trading data show that confusion reigns in equity trading markets. That’s not a mark of rational investment. Money may respond sporadically to earnings, and we do certainly see that. But the broad behavior is a mix of discordant sentiments and reactions. We see that, too. Somebody buys in a dark pool, and programs react to it, and algorithms follow, and speculative traders and all the auto-quote systems (translation: “high frequency trading”) tag along, and none of it knows the worth or driver.

Following rules of deductive reasoning, we conclude that if it’s not rational, it’s something else. What else would it be? Well, what dominates the global financial agenda now? Government debt.

So be ye not lulled into a false sense of security, IR pros. Trouble lurks below the rapids. But for now, we’re rafting on big programs, which seem, right or wrong, to know more than you and me.

Share this article:

More posts

dreamstime m 206876446
February 14, 2024

I’ve got my Valentine, for which I’m grateful every day.  Whether the market finds love after yesterday’s blood remains to be seen. Back when the...

dreamstime m 212403964
February 7, 2024

On Nov 15, 2021, NVDA closed at $345.30 on a hundred million shares of volume. Without context, that information is interesting but unhelpful.  I’d note...

dreamstime l 24803177
January 31, 2024

Consumers are confident. I’m not sure they have all the data. It’s a lesson for public companies. In case you missed it, The Conference Board’s...

dreamstime l 56087804
January 24, 2024

If I said the name “Sherlock Holmes” to you, what’s your snap response? Probably, “Elementary, my dear Watson.” I have long favored a line by...

dreamstime l 50373701
January 17, 2024

What do bitcoin Exchange Traded Funds mean for public companies?   More competition for those dollars you chase with your story. A number of you...

dreamstime m 4397737
January 10, 2024

Total nonfarm payroll employment increased by 216,000 in December. So said the headline from the Bureau of Labor Statistics in its monthly report on jobs...